' ); } ?>

Scale and Diversity in the Future of Business Education

In a now classic Harvard Business Review article published in 1983, Theodore Levitt wrote that the globalization of markets was “at hand” and would bring about the end of the multinational company. In its place would rise truly global companies that “sell the same things the same way everywhere.” Increasingly homogeneous markets would favor companies that could exploit enormous economies of scale.

Thankfully, he was wrong. The truly global companies he imagined, at least in their purest form, do not exist. Nor should they, in my view. And can you imagine what that would look like in business education?

Years ago, I recall Ted Snyder drawing attention to an interesting characteristic of our industry. It was just after he became dean at the Yale School of Management. Even the world’s most prominent business schools, he noted, serve only a tiny slice of the global market for management education. His observation inspired the creation of Global Network for Advanced Management (GNAM) as a way to expand the school’s impact by building connections (combining slices) across the globe.

Our industry is not only fragmented but also remarkably diverse. Business schools differ in size, geographic reach, the range of programs they offer, the types of students they serve, their emphasis on research, and more. In other words, business education is nothing like the globalized, homogeneous market that Levitt imagined.

Lately, I’ve been thinking about the future structure of our industry. Will there be fewer business schools? Some say so. A number of critics even call for shutting down the whole lot. And what about diversity? Will business schools become more homogeneous?

Forces Shaping the Industry

To think about these questions, it is worth considering what we’ve learned about globalization since Levitt’s provocative article. Fellow marketing scholars John Quelch and Philip Kotler helped to explain the balance between international integration and responsiveness to different markets. Pankaj Ghemawat demonstrated the significance of cultural, administrative, geographic, and economic “distances” and helped us appreciate how these differences can be sources of competitive advantage in business. In other words, these scholars suggest that there are natural limits to the globalization of firms and markets.

What about AI’s impact on the industry? Will it reduce the demand for management education? Will it enable some schools to achieve unprecedented global scale while delivering personalized education? I doubt the former, and I’m not convinced that the latter will lead to significant consolidation in our industry. As AI ripples across economies for years to come, it will only increase the need for lifelong learning. And, as AI makes content more accessible, it is both forcing and enabling business schools to move up the value chain—by providing education that is more experiential, personalized, continuous, and social. Even if demand in the MBA market softens at times, I don’t see a compelling reason to expect the outcome to involve significant closures and consolidations, especially since business schools offer a wide range of programs.

But there is another stream of thinking about globalization that is especially important for GBSN’s work. It is less about how companies compete in global markets and more about how economies develop in an increasingly interconnected world. Michael Porter demonstrated how competitive advantage, even in a global economy, can be rooted in local concentrations of knowledge, capabilities, and relationships. Economists like Dani Rodrik and Ricardo Hausmann have helped us to understand that economic development requires more than access to global markets, capital, and technology. It also requires discovering local and national economic opportunities and developing the productive capabilities to realize them.

Society’s biggest development challenges also point to the growing importance of locally embedded capabilities. Geopolitical tensions are reshaping global supply chains. Climate change requires global coordination while generating surprisingly different and difficult local challenges. Demographic shifts mean that some economies are contending with shrinking workforces while others are struggling to create meaningful employment for growing populations—and migration will play an even bigger role in some places. Even AI, with its potential to drive scale in other industries, will generate different economic and social outcomes depending on the communities and companies adopting it.

Building on the Strengths of Business Schools

To me, these developments, especially when combined with growing expectations for business schools to demonstrate impact, create room for more business schools and greater diversity, not less. But they also require business schools to cultivate several strengths. The key is not just to adapt to differences but also to develop the capabilities through which different places can thrive—or flourish. And many of these capabilities cannot be developed by individual organizations acting alone.

First, schools must become more effective at developing ecosystems, not just individuals and organizations. Their relationships with local businesses, governments, entrepreneurs, and civil society—even other universities and business schools—provide opportunities to facilitate collaboration, discover new economic possibilities, and create the conditions for innovation. I will address this topic in more depth in a forthcoming article in EFMD’s Global Focus.

Second, schools must become better at bringing together knowledge from a wider range of disciplines. The challenges facing businesses and communities rarely conform to traditional academic boundaries. I would add here that business schools also have room to improve their capacity to develop durable capabilities, such as critical thinking, creativity, adaptability, and collaboration.

Third, schools must invest in enduring relationships with the communities they serve. Their long-term stake in the economic, social, and environmental development of these communities can distinguish them from other providers of management education and advisory services, who will naturally be more transactional.

These three strengths will enable business schools to compete more effectively while contributing to economic development. Consider the implications for custom executive education. Business schools can generate more value relative to other providers by helping companies strengthen not only their own capabilities but also the ecosystems on which their success depends. They can help identify high-potential industries for investment and, by drawing on disciplines such as engineering, support innovation and growth across traditional boundaries. And because business schools are invested in their communities, they “have skin in the game.”

Even as the competitive dynamic in our industry encourages business schools to emulate one another, I believe the changing environment creates greater opportunities for them to differentiate themselves—not simply as a competitive strategy but as a means of increasing their overall contribution “to addressing the development needs of society,” which happens to be our mission. A business school helping to create entrepreneurial opportunities for young people in an emerging economy can be as important as one advancing the frontiers of management research or developing the leaders of multinational corporations. Growing expectations for impact encourage us to cultivate different areas of strength, rather than reinforce a common model of what a business school looks like.

Realizing the Benefits of Scale

Greater diversity in our industry need not come at the expense of scale. I believe we can realize many of the benefits of scale by working together. At the Global Business School Network (GBSN), we are especially interested in three ways business schools create value together: through real-world learning, shared discovery, and purpose-led collaboration.

In each of these areas, the value of working together derives not only from what business schools have in common, but also from what makes them different—their knowledge, relationships, experiences, and perspectives. When students from different countries come together in teams, they can be more innovative as well as develop cross-cultural agility. When business schools share the costs and benefits of generating knowledge, they contribute to global understanding while enhancing relevance to their own contexts. When we connect complementary institutional capabilities, even within the same community, business schools can take on challenges they could not effectively address alone.

Perhaps the greatest opportunity for our industry is to become more diverse and more interconnected at the same time. The globalization of business education need not mean consolidation or homogenization. In fact, our capacity to contribute to a more prosperous, inclusive, and sustainable world may depend on ensuring that it doesn’t.